Mattingly: Vols have score to settle with these 10

What do North Texas State, Nebraska, Kansas State, Baylor, Dartmouth, VMI, Southern Cal, Purdue, Pittsburgh, and Colorado have in common?

The Vols haven't beaten any of these schools.

Never.

The Vols are suffering through what the baseball folks call an "o-fer."

To rectify this imbalance, let's beat the drum for future games with these schools.

Here's how things have happened historically.

The Vols are 0-1 against North Texas, the school now known as the University of North Texas, considering an embarrassing 21-14 loss at Neyland Stadium Oct. 25, 1975, to the "Mean Green." That came a week after the Vols had lost 30-7 to Alabama at Legion Field.

Tennessee trailed most of the day, but rallied to tie at 14 inside the final five minutes. Then Sears Woods returned the ensuing kickoff 98 yards for a score, and the Vols ended up losing, despite nearly 500 yards total offense. Hayden Fry coached against the Vols at three schools (North Texas, Iowa and SMU) and grabbed the brass ring this day.

The Vols are 0-2 against Nebraska, with losses in the 1998 Orange Bowl (42-17) and the 2000 Fiesta Bowl (31-21). The losses came on either end of the 1998 national championship season. Nebraska just lined up and had their way, playing a physical brand of football. The 1997 contest was the finale for Cornhuskers coach Tom Osborne after 25 years, so the 25-point margin was quite appropriate. Thinking back on the two games, maybe it's better to let sleeping Nebraskans lie.

The Vols are 0-1 against Kansas State, by virtue of a 35-21 loss in the 2001 Cotton Bowl. Vol highlights that day were Chavis Smith, then a defensive tackle, tipping a Wildcats pass that Jabari Greer returned 78 yards for a touchdown and Travis Henry running 81 yards for a score late in the game. The loss broke a six-game winning streak the Vols had produced under the leadership of freshman quarterback Casey Clausen.

The Vols are 0-1 against Baylor. That record dates to the 1957 Sugar Bowl. Final score: Baylor 13, Tennessee 7. Bears quarterback Bob Jones led the way in an outcome Baylor backers didn't really consider an upset. In one of those ironies of history, Jones became a Tennessee assistant, who was killed in that Oct. 18, 1965, car-train wreck. This was also the day Baylor's Larry Hickman kicked Vols guard Bruce Burnham in the head, with Bruce nearly dying on the field as a result.

The Vols are 0-1 against Dartmouth, the result of a 14-3 loss Oct. 15, 1921, in Hanover, N.H. That was so long ago it was on the "Third Saturday in October," and Alabama was nowhere to be found. Two years later, VMI put a 33-0 loss on the Vols on Nov. 17, 1923, and has not been on the schedule since. M. Beal Banks was the head coach both seasons.

Southern Cal, Lane Kiffin's former school, is 4-0 against Tennessee, dating to the 1940 and 1945 Rose Bowls (14-0 and 25-0 Trojans wins, respectively), 1940 being the first foray to the West Coast for a UT football team. There also were games in 1980 and 1981 won by the Trojans, a close one in Knoxville, 20-17, and a 43-7 loss at the Los Angeles Coliseum a year later.

Jeff Fisher, head coach of the Tennessee Titans, was the culprit in 1980, making a key interception that led to the game-winning field goal. The game at the Los Angeles Coliseum nearly wore out the famed USC steed named "Traveler," who galloped around the field each time the Trojans scored.

Purdue took a narrow win (27-22) at the 1979 Astro-Bluebonnet Bowl, despite a dazzling comeback led by Jimmy Streater, James Berry (father of Eric), and Hubert Simpson.

Pittsburgh won twice in Neyland Stadium in 1980 (30-6) and 1983 (13-0). Willie Gault had a 100-yard kickoff return for a score in the 1980 game.

Tennessee and Colorado tied 31-31 in the 1990 season opener at the Disneyland Pigskin Classic at Anaheim Stadium, the baseball field stretching from first base to left field. Tennessee twice trailed by 14 in the fourth quarter, but Andy Kelly, Carl Pickens, and Alvin Harper led the rally to gain the deadlock.

Colorado won a part of the national championship that season, but John Majors thinks had Chuck Webb not been injured against Pacific the next Saturday, the Vols could have done likewise.

Those are teams Tennessee has never beaten.

It's time to balance the accounts.

Scheduling games with Dartmouth and VMI might be a bit iffy, but, with the others, where there's a will, there's a way.

Tom Mattingly is the author of "The Tennessee Football Vault: The Story of the Tennessee Volunteers, 1891-2006" (2006), available now in second edition, and "Tennessee Football: The Peyton Manning Years" (1998). Comments may be sent to tjmshm@comcast.net. His News Sentinel blog is called "The Vol Historian."

Get Copyright Permissions © 2009, Knoxville News Sentinel Co.
Want to use this article? Click here for options!

© 2009 govolsxtra.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

  • Discuss
  • Print

Comments » 22

BasketVols writes:

in response to h8ag8r:

(This comment was removed by the site staff.)

But, wouldn't you love all the smack that Kiffin would talk leading up to the game?

tnmantravel#531151 writes:

the colorod game was great.......if i remember correctly webb was running for the winning touchdown, with the score tied. he was tackled in bounds, close to colorado's goal line, as the clock expired if he had only ran out of bounds on their 20 with 2 or 3 seconds left on the clock, allowing tennessee to line up and kick a chip shot field goal and winning the game......chuck webb is also the best runing back i've ever seen at ut....his game at the cotton bowl against arkansas was 250 rushing yards gained and a mvp award came his way along with a volunteer victory

BasketVols writes:

in response to tnmantravel#531151:

the colorod game was great.......if i remember correctly webb was running for the winning touchdown, with the score tied. he was tackled in bounds, close to colorado's goal line, as the clock expired if he had only ran out of bounds on their 20 with 2 or 3 seconds left on the clock, allowing tennessee to line up and kick a chip shot field goal and winning the game......chuck webb is also the best runing back i've ever seen at ut....his game at the cotton bowl against arkansas was 250 rushing yards gained and a mvp award came his way along with a volunteer victory

How 'bout that 298 yards he dropped on ole miss in 90 or 91? Still the single game record, methinks...

panties4tebow writes:

This article surely was written by John Adams....it seems like the phooey he writes!!!!!!!!!!!!

CoachFulmer writes:

Lets go kick Dartmouth's arse!

gnm53108 writes:

With ya Tom.

Bring em on.

orangebloodgmc writes:

But the last times we faced Michigan, Ohio State, Wisconsin, we went 3-0. Geaux Vawls!

gohawks1 writes:

in response to TCHDWN10C:

(This comment was removed by the site staff.)

I don't know... the Wyoming loss hurt pretty bad last year.

the10sevol writes:

in response to TCHDWN10C:

(This comment was removed by the site staff.)

they were called north texas state, mean joe green's alma mater.
i cried in the stands that day...

Texas_Slim_Bevo writes:

Great read. I love the fact that a couple of high school teams wore you out in that great vol history. Baylor. If you were in the Big XII they would beat you some more. Wow, Baylor.

mattingly writes:

To call the 1990 season a "debacle" is the ultimate in historical revisionism. There were a couple of disappointments, to be sure, at Auburn, against Alabama, but two SEC titles in two years after the 5-6 record in 1988 was a major accomplishment. To say that 1990 was the debacle "that I think cost Johnny his job" is ludicrous. There were events in 1991, the consecutive losses to Alabama and Florida and the second half of the Fiesta Bowl, that should have been indicators, looking back. The 1992 season is well documented by current Vol historians.

How this debate emerged after a story about the "o-fers" in Tennessee history is amazing, to say the least. I "beat" John Adams to this story, for whatever that's worth. I've "beaten" Mike Griffith to at least one, also. They've also "beaten" me to a few, too.

blitzshoot writes:

May want some ammunition before you go hunting.

kiffownsfla writes:

in response to mattingly:

To call the 1990 season a "debacle" is the ultimate in historical revisionism. There were a couple of disappointments, to be sure, at Auburn, against Alabama, but two SEC titles in two years after the 5-6 record in 1988 was a major accomplishment. To say that 1990 was the debacle "that I think cost Johnny his job" is ludicrous. There were events in 1991, the consecutive losses to Alabama and Florida and the second half of the Fiesta Bowl, that should have been indicators, looking back. The 1992 season is well documented by current Vol historians.

How this debate emerged after a story about the "o-fers" in Tennessee history is amazing, to say the least. I "beat" John Adams to this story, for whatever that's worth. I've "beaten" Mike Griffith to at least one, also. They've also "beaten" me to a few, too.

Gotta agree with that for sure! I see the txs slime is back again give it a rest lil zzz how many names u got lmao. GO VOLS!

BigOrangeVol writes:

Bird, Rooster, Berry, Hubert and the rest of the Vols got jobbed by the refs against Purdue!!! We trailed 21-0 in the 3rd Quarter, took the lead at 22-21, before Boilermaker All-American quarterback Mark Herrmann led the final game-winning rally with 1:30 left in the game. Herrmann had 303 total yards with Bart Burrell receiving 144 on 8 catches . They also had Keena Turner on Defense. Jimmy threw and ran for 270 yards and Anthony had 116 yards receiving. Roland James was the Defensive MVP.

We had some all-time greats on the '79 team! Danny Spradlin; Craig Puki; Danny Martin; Bill Bates; John Warren; Reggie Harper; Lee North; Tim Irwin; Alan Duncan; Steve Davis; Kenny Jones; Brad White and Brian Ingram along with Jimmy, Anthony, Berry and Hubert.

BTW, this article FIRST appeared in the KNS... LAST YEAR on July 4th.!!! http://blogs.knoxnews.com/knx/matting...

volboy81 writes:

I've looked at these teams several times and thought the exact same thing, Mr Mattingly. Thanks for bringing it to everyone's attention! I say we get them all on future schedules. A home and away series for most of them would be great! Lets even the score or get one-up on them!!

volboy81 writes:

in response to Texas_Slim_Bevo:

Great read. I love the fact that a couple of high school teams wore you out in that great vol history. Baylor. If you were in the Big XII they would beat you some more. Wow, Baylor.

I seem to recall Baylor beating Texas a few times..once leaving the score lit up all night. I think Rice has a W or 2 vs. you too...fairly recently...Rice? Really?

bigaldaddy writes:

Sorry Tom, this is not one of your best.

Ralph_Crampton writes:

Mattingly is fine historian on the part of the Volunteers.

Ralph_Crampton writes:

I think we should take a look at the past Tennessee coaches over the tears...We'll start about 1926...generally considered the start of the modern area of the pigskin sport. The top Vol coach of all time--Bob Neyland would be ranked first. 2. John Barnhill, 3. Doug Dickey.4 Philip Fulmer, 5. Tie- between Bill Battle and Johnny Majors. The top recruiters of all Vols'. 1. Doug Dickey, 2. Philip Fulmer, 3. Bob Neyland, 4. John Barnhill, 5.Johnny Majors. The best on-the-field coach during a game: 1. Bob Neyland, 2. John Barnhill, 3. Doug Dickey, 4. Bowden Wyatt, 5. Philip Fulmer - tie with Johnny Majors. The coach who got the most out of his players: 1. Bob Neyland, 2. John Barnhill, 3 Doug Dickey, 4. Philip Fulmer, 5. Bowden Wyatt. The top defensive coach: 1. Bob Neyland, 2. John Barnhill, 3. Bowden Wyatt, 4. Doug Dickey, 5. Bill Battle. In a follow-up, I will explain my picks thoroughly. What do you think?

LiveFaith writes:

in response to panties4tebow:

This article surely was written by John Adams....it seems like the phooey he writes!!!!!!!!!!!!

Don't say anything about Adams, or all the "professional" cronies will get together and give him another award.

Bufforange00 writes:

Tennessee never won a NC under Majors because he couldn't beat Alabama-just as Fulmer had trouble with UF. The 1989 team was very good, but got smacked down 47-30 by Siran Stacy and co.-(Bama also went 10-1 regular season and played eventual champ Miami in the Sugar Bowl). The next year, Bama was 2-5 when they came to K-town (UT was undefeated and #3) and Bama still won 9-6. At least UF was usually a better team when they beat UT. Those Bama games were very frustrating.

TennCup writes:

in response to Texas_Slim_Bevo:

Great read. I love the fact that a couple of high school teams wore you out in that great vol history. Baylor. If you were in the Big XII they would beat you some more. Wow, Baylor.

If Tejas had been good enough to be in the Cotton Bowl that year, we'd have played you. Where were you in 1956?

Share your thoughts

Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned. Click here for our full user agreement.

Comments can be shared on Facebook and Yahoo!. Add both options by connecting your profiles.

Features