Tom Mattingly: Coaching changes often lead to clashes

Interesting things can happen when one coach leaves and another takes his place.

It's a classic case of getting people's attention and showing you mean business. Things get "real."

Very quickly.

In 1926, Capt. Robert R. Neyland had to "lock his jaw" with Dean Nathan Washington Dougherty and take on the baseball and track coaches to get enough players to hold spring practice.

"You hired me to coach football," he told members of the athletics board, "and if we are going to have a football team, we must have the best spring practice we have ever had. If I can't have every single one of them as long as I want them, I can't operate."

Then Neyland played his strongest card.

"Let somebody else take the job. I won't have it. I'll leave it with you."

The exact details of what happened are not readily known, but Dean Dougherty later told Neyland to go ahead with spring practice. Neyland said later that the 1926 spring practice was the "catalyst" for the success of that season and for the seasons to follow.

"That was the first d--- time I had to lock my jaw," Neyland said.

In 1955, Bowden Wyatt lost his best running back on the second day of spring drills, when he and star running back Tom Tracy, a 1954 All-SEC selection who rushed for a team-leading 794 yards, parted ways.

"Tom was not a proponent of strict training rules," Marvin West wrote.

In the spring of 1955, Tracy suffered leg cramps and lay in a heap on the field. Wyatt moved the team down the field, and drills continued.

"Tracy was offended by this lack of official compassion," Marvin added. "That evening, he threatened to leave. Wyatt dispatched two assistants to help him pack."

The impact was two-fold.

"Losing Tracy was a sizeable setback. Establishing authority enhanced Wyatt's influence." There were any number of players who said they'd "run through a wall" for their head coach.

In 1964, Steve DeLong had a running battle with new coach Doug Dickey that West helped recount. Steve was a 1963 All-America selection at middle guard and seemed more than willing to help the rookie coach. Dickey, however, wasn't very receptive to Steve's offer of assistance.

"He called me into his office for a meeting," DeLong said. "I had been through enough by then to not be intimidated. Coach Dickey said he wasn't sure he could use me on the 1964 team. He said I might make it as an offensive tackle."

The idea of DeLong as an offensive tackle after an All-America season on defense seemed equivalent to running Secretariat in the back yard, but DeLong and Dickey reached enough of an agreement to make it through the season. DeLong again earned All-America honors and won the Outland Trophy as the nation's best interior lineman, again anchoring the defensive line. Beginning in 1965, Dickey had the Vol program reaching for the stars.

In his autobiography, Johnny Majors recalled a memory about "snuff cups" early in his tenure at Tennessee.

"The first time I met with the Tennessee players after the announcement had been made I was to be their new head coach, some of them showed up carrying snuff cups."

Bad move.

"Now I know a number of fine people who go around with a big chew of tobacco in their mouths, but I don't think our athletes should show up at a squad meeting dipping snuff. That rule went into effect right away."

There are other times reality sets in, with a personal cost.

Everybody remembers "National Signing Day," when everybody's a hero, when everybody can play. The sky's the limit. The recruits are the toast of the town. Better days are just around the corner. Fans begin mentally chalking up the wins.

Here's what happens.

Some of the recruits can play.

Some can't.

When that latter reality sets in, you can tell it by the body language. The eyes are the key. When a player is thinking about leaving, you can see it in the eyes.

Then comes the phone call to a favored reporter and the ensuing press release, stating that a certain player has "left the squad." That's the description of choice.

Sometimes the coach says, "We wish him well." Sometimes he doesn't. Then follows a recapitulation of that player's career.

After that, the talk shows kick into gear, and, 99 times out of 100, the coach is the heavy, either for poor recruiting judgment or "mistreating" or "misleading" a seemingly popular player, particularly one from the vicinity of Knoxville.

The truth lies somewhere in between. The situation is magnified when a new coach comes in and some recruits fall by the wayside, or never even get a sniff from the new staff.

Looking over each year's recruiting class, it is often surprising how many "make it" . . . and how many don't.

It's a reflection of life as we know it.

Then and now.

Tom Mattingly is a freelance contributor.

Get Copyright Permissions © 2011, Knoxville News Sentinel Co.
Want to use this article? Click here for options!

© 2011 All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

  • Discuss
  • Print

Comments » 9

VOLliven2it writes:

The truth is simple, coaching changes have many challenges. The way one leaves and the way the next one comes in impacts everything. So as fans we must be patient and realize our team will still have troubles. As for the first post on this article, we do not yet know just how good the 2011 team will be. They may not be world-beaters but if I was(but I'm not)a betting man, I'd wager we will see a better effort than last year and if we can just wait another year with more continuity in 2012, they will be contenders. The first poster just must be a prophet. I would love to hear his or her story of how they took a similar stint to what Coach Dooley faced and made it an instant success. On second I don't. I wouldn't believe it anyway!

mountainbrook writes:

in response to Mama_Calls_Me_Precious:

(This comment was removed by the site staff.)

As opposed to your bottom of the pack post. Poor effort. I give you a D.

FWBVol writes:

in response to Mama_Calls_Me_Precious:

(This comment was removed by the site staff.)

Yes, you might be right about this year's team, but let's be realistic. This is the first time since 2007-2008 that the same head coach, and for the most, coaching staff has been in place for the football team. There have been volumes written about the attrition that has taken place since Fulmer was fired.

Rebuilding takes time, and I beleive brighter days are ahead. Realistically, I can see us finishing anywhere from first to fourth in the SEC East this year, probably third.

I don't think there have ever been as many teams with as many questions heading into a season as there are this year.

I believe the future is bright for Tennessee.

stormblast writes:

in response to Mama_Calls_Me_Precious:

(This comment was removed by the site staff.)

Ahhhhh, more reading from the twit.

stormblast writes:

in response to Tweetdriver63:

(This comment was removed by the site staff.)

I wonder if its the morbidly obese chick from the Precious movie.

Or someone like the mom from Gilbert Grape. "Arnie, you're my knight in shimmering armour. Hand mama that laptop so I can talk to my friends. Where's Gilbert. Gilbert!!!"

give_him_6 writes:

in response to Mama_Calls_Me_Precious:

(This comment was removed by the site staff.)

LoL...your mama calls you precious cause you ride the small bus... you dipsh*t!!!

volnsc51 writes:

in response to Navalorange:

(This comment was removed by the site staff.)

For a price

BigVolinCarolina writes:

Am I to read between the lines that there was a clash between Coach Martin and Harris? Or Martin and Hopson?

Just curious. The timing of the article raises questions, in my opinion. Not sure if Mattingly is simply talking, or if he's hinting at the present state of UT basketball with Harris and Hopson deciding to go pro.

mocsandvolsfan writes:

Too historical and too thoughtful. But I guess it's all ifs and maybes this time of year. Depressing. Now let's play FOOTBALL! GBO

Want to participate in the conversation? Become a subscriber today. Subscribers can read and comment on any story, anytime. Non-subscribers will only be able to view comments on select stories.