New Jersey governor wants to talk with Rutgers about former UT coach Julie Hermann

Former UT volleyball players said she ruled through humiliation, fear, emotional abuse

Julie Hermann listens as Rutgers President Robert Barchi announces Hermann as athletic director, Wednesday, May 15, 2013, in Piscataway, N.J. Hermann, who was Louisville's senior associate athletic director, will be the third female athletic director at a school among the 124 playing at college football's top tier. Rutgers has been looking for a new AD since Tim Pernetti resigned on April 5, part of the fallout from the Mike Rice scandal. (AP Photo/Mel Evans)

Photo by AP Photo/Mel Evans

Julie Hermann listens as Rutgers President Robert Barchi announces Hermann as athletic director, Wednesday, May 15, 2013, in Piscataway, N.J. Hermann, who was Louisville's senior associate athletic director, will be the third female athletic director at a school among the 124 playing at college football's top tier. Rutgers has been looking for a new AD since Tim Pernetti resigned on April 5, part of the fallout from the Mike Rice scandal. (AP Photo/Mel Evans)

NEWARK, N.J. (AP) — New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie plans to speak with Rutgers officials about a report that the athletic director hired to clean up the school's scandal-scarred program quit as Tennessee's women's volleyball coach 16 years ago after her players complained she ruled through humiliation, fear and emotional abuse.

Christie spokesman Michael Drewniak says the governor is aware of the report about Julie Hermann in The Star-Ledger of Newark, but wants to get more details before commenting.

"He's not going to make any judgments at this time," Drewniak said in an email to The Associated Press on Sunday.

The Star-Ledger reported that Tennessee players wrote the mentality cruelty they suffered when Hermann was coach was unbearable, adding she called them "whores, alcoholics and learning disabled."

Hermann was hired May15 to replace the ousted Tim Pernetti, who was let go after basketball coach Mike Rice was fired for abusive behavior.

The 49-year-old Hermann is scheduled to take over at Rutgers on June 17. She is set to become the first woman to run the Scarlet Knights' athletic program and one of three female ADs at the 124 schools playing at college football's top tier.

However, it's uncertain whether the report will force Rutgers to re-consider the appointment. It also could give impetus to those who want new Rutgers President Robert Barchi to step down after yet another black eye for the state's largest university.

The university had not issued a comment by 5 p.m. Sunday.

Hermann was not immediately available for comment, but told The Star-Ledger that she did not recall the Tennessee letter. The newspaper said when it was read to her by phone, she replied, "Wow."

Rutgers board members Candace Straight and Joseph J. Roberts Jr. didn't return telephone calls by the AP seeking comment.

"The questionable decision-making at this program so heavily funded by taxpayers continues to astound me," Assembly speaker Sheila Oliver said in an email to the AP.

New Jersey state Sen. Ray Lesniak said in a telephone interview with The AP that Barchi "has proven not to be up to the task" and has written a letter to Christie recommending that Pernetti be given the job back, adding he has been a scapegoat from the start.

A couple of Hermann's colleagues came to her defense.

Louisville volleyball coach Anne Kordes has known Hermann as a coach and a former Cardinals' student-athlete for 15 years.

I have only known Julie to conduct herself with the highest level of professionalism and integrity," Kordes said in an email. "She serves as an incredible role model for female athletes, coaches, and administrators and has always made it clear that she is supportive of her coaches starting and expanding family."

Susan Bassett, the director of athletics at Carnegie Mellon University, has worked with Hermann on the NACWAA Board of Directors for the past 10 years and said she has been the consummate professional whose philosophy of sport is absolutely aligned with the academic mission of her University, the NCAA, and NACWAA.

" I know through her support of Louisville student-athletes and the mentoring of aspiring female administrators through NACWAA programming, Julie Hermann has the best interests of all human beings at heart," Bassett said in an email. "Respect and common decency are core values for her, which pervade her work. "

Louisville Athletic Director Tom Jurich, who was Hermann's boss for almost the last 16 years, was surprised by the report.

"For me to say this is a shock, it totally is because of the tremendous job she did for me," Jurich said Sunday in a telephone interview. "When she was with me at Northern Arizona, her players adored and loved her. I never heard anything about this at all from the Tennessee players and a lot of them have come through Louisville a number of times. Everybody is always singing her praises."

The Star-Ledger report said that wasn't the case late in her coaching career at Tennessee.

In the letter submitted by all 15 team members in 1996, the volleyball players said Hermann called them "whores, alcoholics and learning disabled" and they wrote: "It has been unanimously decided that this is an irreconcilable issue." The players told The Star-Ledger that Hermann absorbed the words and said: "I choose not to coach you guys."

After a series of interviews with many of the former Tennessee players about Hermann, The Star-Ledger said:

"Their accounts depict a coach who thought nothing of demeaning them, who would ridicule and laugh at them over their weight and their performances, sometimes forcing players to do 100 sideline pushups during games, who punished them after losses by making them wear their workout clothes inside out in public or not allowing them to shower or eat, and who pitted them against one another, cutting down particular players with the whole team watching, and through gossip.

"Several women said playing for Hermann had driven them into depression and counseling, and that her conduct had sullied the experience of playing Division I volleyball."

The Star-Ledger asked Hermann about the players' lingering grievances.

"I never heard any of this, never name-calling them or anything like that whatsoever," she told the newspaper. "None of this is familiar to me."

Hermann had promised a restart the Rutgers' athletic program following the ouster of its men's basketball coach and the resignation of other officials.

"No one on the coaching staff doesn't believe that we need to be an open book, that we will no longer have any practice, anywhere at any time, that anybody couldn't walk into and be pleased about what's going on in that environment. It is a new day. It is already fixed," Hermann said at her introductory news conference.

At that news conference, Hermann was questioned about a 1997 jury verdict that awarded $150,000 to a former Tennessee assistant coach who said Hermann fired her because she became pregnant.

Rutgers' problems started in December when Rice was suspended three games and fined $75,000 by the school after a video of his conduct at practices was given to Pernetti by Eric Murdock, a former assistant coach. The video showed numerous clips of Rice firing basketballs at players, hitting them in the back, legs, feet and shoulders. It also showed him grabbing players by their jerseys and yanking them around the court. Rice can also be heard yelling obscenities and using anti-gay slurs.

The controversy went public in April when ESPN aired the videos and Barchi admitted he didn't view the video in the fall. Rice was fired and Pernetti, assistant coach Jimmy Martelli and interim senior vice president and university counsel John Wolf resigned.

Even when Rutgers has made a move that was well received, there was a glitch.

After hiring former Scarlet Knights star Eddie Jordan to take over the basketball program, the university made the mistake of calling him a graduate when he had never finished work for his degree.

Now the Hermann problem has popped up when many thought the worst was over, and that the athletic department could start focusing on its move to the Big Ten in 2014.

To read the Star-Ledger's report and video coverage go to NJ.com.

Get Copyright Permissions © 2013, The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.
Want to use this article? Click here for options!

  • Discuss
  • Print

Related Topics

Related Stories

Comments » 14

Witch_Doctors writes:

Witch Doctor bet she a fun person though! Witch Doctor cant help at laugh at this for some reason, some of the names and they had to write a letter because they were scared..lol. Witch Doctor say from the outside looks like she may have been right! haha
Bones never lie.

BetsyVol writes:

She seems to “suffer” from CRS, Can’t Remember Squat.

Doesn’t remember when her team issued a vote of no confidence.

Doesn’t remember a wedding she was at that was a critical part of a lawsuit that she lost….

Most “ladies” outgrow CRS about the time they turn 18 or 19.

eVOLved writes:

Pardon WD, he's thinking with his pagan ceremonial divining rod instead of his brain. Chris Christie just hates strong females--he's intimidated by J WoW and Snooki, and he's intimidates by the former Alpha Female UT coach.

BIVOLAR_BEARE writes:

Christie just wants another excuse to binge eat..

lemme_axya_this writes:

in response to BIVOLAR_BEARE:

Christie just wants another excuse to binge eat..

Very funny, I'll bet the skeletons in his closet have been picked clean.

Witch_Doctors writes:

in response to eVOLved:

Pardon WD, he's thinking with his pagan ceremonial divining rod instead of his brain. Chris Christie just hates strong females--he's intimidated by J WoW and Snooki, and he's intimidates by the former Alpha Female UT coach.

Witch Doctor say must be the weather or something? lol
Bones never lie.

rockypop writes:

There's a message here for all current players, coaches and administrators - that is, you better consider your actions every day. We live in a world where anybody in the public eye is constantly scrutinized and even monitored by a variety of devices - both public and private.

Be a jerk, misfit, or tyrant at your own risk. It will catch up with you no matter how forcefully you deny or pretend you don't remember it. And, the most vulnerable among all those who exhibit these characteristics are those who aren't winners.

utvolfan1955 writes:

in response to Hacaf1965:

(This comment was removed by the site staff.)

If only the KNS could can your ip address

chipmurphy461 writes:

On the surface, it's one thing if an individual player accuses a coach of an act, but it is a completely different matter if an entire team accuses a coach of something! That said, people can and do evolve. If I were Rutgers and attempting to return a sense of dignity to my university and athletic programs there's no way I would even interview a candidate with the slightest blemish on their record let alone hire someone with a questionable background relevant to the same scenario we're trying to remedy. Rutgers must hire someone else and let another school give her a chance to prove herself as a Division I AD.

madmax22 writes:

If I were Rutgers, it wouldn't trouble me as much as what she may or may have not done as a coach 20 years ago, as much it would how easily she seems to lie now. To claim there was no video, didn't remember going to a wedding she was a bridesmaid and didn't recall a letter from the team that was in effect the reason for her reassignment shows a total lack of character. Looks like she should be more suited for a job in the Obama administration.

madrigal writes:

in response to chipmurphy461:

On the surface, it's one thing if an individual player accuses a coach of an act, but it is a completely different matter if an entire team accuses a coach of something! That said, people can and do evolve. If I were Rutgers and attempting to return a sense of dignity to my university and athletic programs there's no way I would even interview a candidate with the slightest blemish on their record let alone hire someone with a questionable background relevant to the same scenario we're trying to remedy. Rutgers must hire someone else and let another school give her a chance to prove herself as a Division I AD.

It's possible for people to change and evolve, but they needed to do a better investigation of the incidents here as well as wherever she went next. Volleyball is considered a "minor" sport at most schools and it would certainly be possible for a lot to get by under the radar. Considering the mess their men's basketball coaching situation turned into, Rutgers does not need someone as AD that has this kind of cloud hanging over her.

For those of you who are still making jokes about Gov. Christie's weight, it must have escaped you that he had lap-band surgery a few weeks ago. Whether you like the guy or not, cut him some slack. And do try to keep up!

OwensboroVol writes:

Just about all coaches are known to be tough on players verbally. What concerns me was the claim that she committed physical violence on players. I believe that in these days, actions such as these disqualify a person for a job in this area particularly dealing directly with the Student/Athlete. Its up to Rutgers, but as a Tennessee Alumni I'm sure glad she is not part of the Tennessee Family any longer. There is absolutely no reason why the Volleyball Players from the 1990's brought this up to benefit themselves. There is no benefit to them.

AllforTenn writes:

in response to Hacaf1965:

(This comment was removed by the site staff.)

Why did you quit your billythekid moniker? Lose what little credibility you might have had, which was none?

AllforTenn writes:

in response to AllforTenn:

Why did you quit your billythekid moniker? Lose what little credibility you might have had, which was none?

Meant this for the new Hacal1965, billythekid dude.

Want to participate in the conversation? Become a subscriber today. Subscribers can read and comment on any story, anytime. Non-subscribers will only be able to view comments on select stories.

Features